Should I Get a Conservatory or an Extension

Posted February 28, 2017

With many homeowners looking to expand their property – be that for extra living space, sun rooms, home offices or other reasons, the question of how best to get that space is a popular one.

Loft conversions are common, so too cellar conversions, though both of these can end up being very expensive options – costs such as tanking a cellar often being greater than the cost of simply building a brand new addition to the house.

And that is perhaps why conservatories and extensions seem to be the most popular projects – but which one of these is the best option for you?

An increasingly nuanced choice

Perhaps the choice used to be a bit easier.

If you just wanted a room from which to enjoy a few sunny, summer afternoons then you would go for a conservatory; if you wanted anything able to provide a wider range of uses then it had to be an extension.20160525_101450

The cost differences also often led homeowners one way or another – one being a relatively cheap project compared to the overall value of the house, the other perhaps requiring more significant borrowing or remortgaging of the property.

But knowledge also played a part. Anyone with experience of conservatories up to a few years ago was probably aware of their flaws. Any conservatory made with a glass or polycarbonate roof is simply unable to regulate the temperatures – the room becoming far too hot in the summer and too cold in winter.

For many, this knowledge made it a simpler decision – extension or nothing.

Recent changes have, however, served to make it a much more complex decision.

New conservatories – all the benefits of an extension?

Conservatories can now come in a format that looks more like an extension than a conservatory. A bit confusing perhaps, but also great news for anyone previously unsure which to choose.

Now there is a middle ground with some of the best features of both.

These new style conservatories have one fundamental difference from their older cousins – they don’t use a glass or polycarb roof, instead they have a lightweight solid, tiled roof.Townsend_1

This roof makes the conservatories usable all year round, yet is light enough to sit on a traditional conservatory construction. The build time and cost is therefore more in keeping with a conservatory; the year-round usability more in keeping with what you would expect of an extension.

At Guardian, we are the only company to make these solid, tiled roofs to a standard that receives full Local Area Building Control approval. In fact, it was us who developed this type of room; believing it must be possible to come up with a lightweight, effective alternative to the flawed roofs of the past.

The same difference?

The advances made to conservatory roofs mean that for many purposes there is very little difference between the two.

Extensions and conservatories can now both be enjoyable spaces all year round suitable for a whole range of uses. Both also blend in sympathetically to the rest of the property – no longer are conservatories a glass bolt-on, instead the roofs come in a range of styles and subtle colours ensuring they closely match the rest of the house.

And both even have the huge advantage of adding value to the property. Of course, it varies by postcode, type of house and other factors, but both can be appealing to would-be buyers in future. In many cases, conservatories with solid roofs more than pay for themselves; the money spent on them being less than the increased value of the property when it is later sold.

However, some differences remain…

Specialist space

For some purposes, for all the advances seen in conservatory build quality, extensions are still the best choice.

Larger builds of course can be better suited to extensions too – a two-storey extension might prove a cost effective way of getting extra living space downstairs as well as an extra bedroom on the upper floor.

In general, though, conservatories are an under appreciated alternative. They perhaps still suffer from the reputation they had for being too hot in the summer and too cold in the winter, yet neither of these is an issue any more thanks to changes in legislation to allow our solid, tiled roofs.

Some advice

With it being so nuanced a choice nowadays, with little to choose between extensions and conservatories; why not get in touch for an obligation free chat?

At Guardian we convert existing conservatories by replacing the roof, while we also build new conservatories and extensions.

Please get in touch by calling 0800 066 5832 or by visiting this page.